ShieldPack SHIELD PACK
With you since 2022

Where would you like to start?

Services, updates, and ways to contact us, all in one place

Pricing and orders →

Use the bot or chat with us—whichever you prefer

ShieldPack posts

Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Facebook's Android Gallery Access Without Explicit Consent

About 4 min read

Meta Inc. has been hit with a €805 million penalty by Italy’s data‑protection regulator, the Garante, after it was found that a Facebook feature for Android devices automatically suggested photos and videos from users’ phone galleries without obtaining clear, separate consent. The sanction, announced yesterday, marks one of the steepest fines levied against the company for a privacy breach in the European Union.
The contested feature works by scanning a handset’s image library and offering suggested media for posting, drawing on the phone’s photos, videos and associated metadata. According to the Garante’s investigation, the function was turned on by default when users installed the app, and the permission granted covered the entire application rather than the specific gallery‑suggestion capability. The regulator noted that a generic notice about enabling other functions appeared first, but it failed to make clear that users were also activating the gallery‑suggestion tool. As a result, the app could read the full photo archive on an ongoing basis, and neither users nor the authority could verify exactly which data were being utilized.
The authority deemed the practice a breach of Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which incorporates the EU’s ePrivacy Directive into national law. That provision treats a mobile phone as part of an individual’s private sphere, meaning any access to stored content requires a freely given, informed consent, irrespective of whether the data are transmitted elsewhere or cause any demonstrable harm. By enabling the feature without a distinct opt‑in, Meta violated the rule that personal devices must not be accessed without explicit permission.
In response, the Garante issued a compliance order that gives Meta 60 days to deactivate the gallery‑suggestion function by default, even for users who have previously allowed the app to read their gallery. The company must also request separate consent for the feature moving forward. Should the deadline be missed, the regulator stipulated that the function may not be re‑enabled for any user lacking valid consent, effectively barring the feature until proper permission is obtained.
Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Facebook's Android Gallery Access Without Explicit Consent
Meta has announced its intention to appeal the decision, describing the fine as “disproportionate.” In a statement referenced by Reuters, the company argued that the feature only operates after a user grants device‑level permission and that such permission can be revoked at any time through the phone’s settings. Meta also contended that the case should have been handled by Ireland’s data‑protection authority, a claim the Garante rejected on the grounds that the ePrivacy rules do not provide a one‑stop‑shop mechanism for cross‑border enforcement.
The investigation was triggered by a complaint from the Bolzano‑based consumer‑rights group Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti. The group issued public advice on 11 July 2025, urging users to turn off the gallery‑suggestion setting within the app and to review the permissions granted to Facebook on their devices. The Garante’s technical analysis began in July 2025 and focused on the feature that has been available since 2023. The probe did not examine whether the accessed gallery content was employed to train artificial‑intelligence models—a claim the company denies—but the regulator signaled that a newer cloud‑processing feature launched this year may be scrutinised separately.
The fine represents roughly 0.47 % of Meta’s worldwide revenue, a calculation the authority used to underscore the scale of the infringement. It also reflected the large number of affected individuals—about 20 million Android users in Italy—alongside the duration of the breach, which remains ongoing for users who have not updated the app and for those who previously granted permission. The Garante took into account a prior 2019 decision against Meta and noted the company’s limited cooperation during the investigation; while some remedial steps were taken after the complaint, the regulator judged them to be late and applicable only to users who update the app.
Overall, the case highlights the growing scrutiny of tech firms’ handling of personal data on mobile devices, especially as privacy regulators across Europe tighten enforcement of the ePrivacy framework. For ShieldPack readers, the ruling serves as a reminder to regularly audit app permissions on Android devices and to stay alert to default settings that may silently harvest personal media. The outcome may also influence how other platforms design consent flows for features that tap into users’ private photo libraries, potentially prompting broader industry shifts toward more transparent, opt‑in‑based architectures.

Source: The Hacker News · Cybersecurity

ShieldPack media